Thursday, November 21, 2013

Argumentative Essay 2nd Draft

Gabriel Solis
Ms. Matyakubova
English 110, Section F
26 October 2013
Argumentative Essay

Video Games: A Rising Art Form

The definition of art and whether something is considered to be art is a subject that is cursed to an eternity of debate. With the rising popularity of new entertainment mediums comes the argument of whether the new form is art. Video games are no exception to this debate. As years pass by and technology advances, the graphical capabilities, along with other aspects of games, have matured since the early days of gaming. Arguments on whether video games are a form of art or not have grown with the release of bigger and better looking games that rival the production values of big Hollywood films. Such games have supported the belief that games are indeed an art form, yet some people remain unconvinced. While the definition of art in the modern world has become rather subjective, one can consider that there is general consensus on the basics of what makes something art. With that in mind, one can argue that in contemporary society, video games are a form of art.  
To argue whether something is or is not art, one must first become familiar with a basic understanding of art. According to the official Webster Dictionary, art is “something that is created with imagination and skill and that is beautiful or that expresses important ideas or feelings” (“Art”). Considering this definition, art is something that someone or some people must create in their imagination and put it to life in a way that others can see and draw  beauty from or interpret a message or expression that the artist is trying to display. This can be directly applied to video game developers in their process of making a game. A team of artists work together to create a world in which their game will take place in along with characters with unique designs. A team of writers collaborate on a story for their game. They create backstories for main characters, a main plot with a central conflict and sometimes focus on a theme that they want their players to experience and understand their message on a certain topic. Then programmers work on bringing everything together into a functional game that players can watch, listen and interact with in the hopes that they will see and feel what the developers intended. Of course, like other forms of art like paintings and poems, people will interpret the same piece in several different ways. Some players will complete The Last of Us and feel differently about the characters and develop their own theories on what happened after the game ended. Art is about creating something with the intention of showing others to see and interpret a message and emotion from, which is exactly what video games can accomplish when done right. 
Continuing with the aforementioned definition of art, storytelling is a major part games that can express important feelings and ideas just like a book or other written works. With higher production values and advancing technology, developers have been able to find new ways to develop engaging storytelling techniques perviously unavailable. In the critical essay “Short Controlled Bursts: Affect and Aliens” by Henry Jenkins and Matthew Weise, 
Many film critics saw [Steven] Spielberg's recruitment as Hollywood coming to rescue its fledgling digital counterpart: the director of screen melodramas was being hired to teach the games industry how enriching character and storytelling could achieve greater emotional impact than games currently on the market, 
in response to filmmaker Steven Spielberg’s 2005 announcement of a contract with video game publisher Electronic Arts to help develop three games. This shows how people saw (and still see) video games as a primitive entertainment medium trying to achieve a similar status to film and dismissed its storytelling techniques. However, “Industry insiders, by contrast, argued that games had already achieved plenty of emotional impact by deploying their own techniques and exploiting their own distinctive properties as a medium,” (Jenkins, Weise). This is very true in games with a strong narrative such as the Mass Effect series where the player can drive the story based on conversation choices the player makes with the other characters. Many role-playing games (RPGs) take advantage of this ability to allow the player to control the story and allow for multiple outcomes depending on what the player chooses. Many games have been praised for the useful implementation of this for allowing the player to feel more immersed in the story and its characters and possibly even have an emotional bond with certain characters. This, again, relates back to art being something that can invoke emotional responses in people, something that can be done masterfully in games. 
Visuals are another major, if not the most important, aspect of games. Video games originated from humble beginnings with little to no visual graphics due to the limited technology in the late 1960s and early 70s. However, even in the times of video game’s infancy, game’s limited, pixel graphics were part of the charm of the game and forced the player to use their imagination of what the game is trying to show. In fact, most of the visual art work came from the box art. Box arts were usually very detailed and painted a very good picture of what the developer wanted the player to see when playing the game. Of course, the game looked almost nothing like the box art, so the player’s imagination had fill in the blanks. For example, the box art for Castlevania: 
,
hardly looked like the game itself: 

Courtesy of Konami
Now with much more advanced technology, graphics have improved at an exponential rate with today’s games looking close enough to real life to the point where it may even be hard to distinguish the two: 
Courtesy of Turn 10 Studios
Video games have reached a point to where an average person may not even be able to figure out that the top half of the picture above is actually a screen shot from Forza Motorsport 4, whereas the bottom picture is a real life photo. While the increase in visual possibilities in games may have erased the use of imagination, strong visuals in games on its own can tell a story and add to the overall experience, similar to paintings and sculptures. If visual artwork in video games are capable of creating pieces that can invoke awe and receive emotional responses from its beauty similar to paintings and sculptures in art museums, then it is safe to say that video games are art. 
Despite these connections between video games and other well established forms of art, people still remain unconvinced and retain their firm beliefs of why video games are not and cannot be art. Renowned film critic Roger Ebert wrote a piece in his personal online journal titled (appropriately) “Video Games Can Never Be Art” where he stated, “I remain convinced that in principle, video games cannot be art,” and went on to say, “No one in or out of the field has ever been able to cite a game worthy of comparison with the great poets, filmmakers, novelists and poets.” Therefore, he believes video games will never reach the status as an art form because there are no well-known developers that have similar fame as people such as Edgar Allan Poe or Alfred Hitchcock or   Even well-respected Japanese video game developer Hideo Kojima, famous for his Metal Gear Solid series, stated in an interview with Official Playstation 2 Magazine US that he agreed with Ebert’s statement (Gibson). They see video games as more of a business simply interested in getting as many people as possible to buy their game. This is absolutely true about the video game industry. The industry is a business that, like any other business, is interested in making money. That does not, however, negate the artistic values in the games. While games are trying to appeal to the widest audience, they do it with their own unique artistic direction whether through the visual artwork, story, subject matter, or even music. Developers try their best to infuse their artistic visions in their games in a way that players can enjoy and appreciate and even understand messages that the developers are trying to tell the players, just like other forms of art. While arguments made by people like Ebert and Kojima who do not believe video games are art are valid, they lack to see the true potential behind video games and what they can achieve artistically. They also fail to see the advantage of player interaction in games. Other mediums like movies and books are mainly just people consuming the piece the way the author intended and people come up with their own interpretations. The added ability of interaction in games gives an extra dimension for developers and players alike to explore new ways of interaction and communication, which is a major component of art, the communication of emotions and ideas. 
Art is not an easy subject to tackle. Even with a general understanding of what makes something art, alternate interpretations make the subject a very delicate one. Nevertheless, video games have evolved to allow it to be considered great works of art. Granted, not every game is set out to be one and not every game that tries to be one succeeds. However, there is no doubt that with the possibilities in games today, video games can be considered great works of art. Like movies and books, not every game will strike an emotional chord in everyone and be the next Picasso or Citizen Kane. However, if naysayers like Roger Ebert had the chance to play certain games today like The Last of Us, maybe even he would see why so many people agree in saying video games are art.          




Works Cited 
Castlevania Box Art. 1987. Photograph. Konami. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
 Castlevania Screen Shot. 1987. Photograph. Konami. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
 Ebert, Roger. "Video Games Can Never Be Art." Roger Ebert, 16 Apr. 2010. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
 Forza Motorsport 4 Screen Shot. N.d. Photograph. Forzamotorsport.net. Turn 10 Studios, 2011. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
 Gibson, Ellie. "Games Aren't Art, Says Kojima." Eurogamer.net, 24 Jan. 2006. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
 Goldman, Johnathan. "Art." Webster's Dictionary. 2000. Print.

 Jenkins, Henry, and Weise, Matthew. "Short Controlled Bursts: Affect and Aliens."Literature Resource Center. CCNY, Spring 2008. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.

No comments:

Post a Comment