Thursday, November 21, 2013

Journal 8

Gabriel Solis 
Ms. Matyakubova
English 110, Section F
3 November 2013
Journal 8
Black Friday

“Black Friday: Consumerism Minus Civilization” by Andrew Leonard is clearly trying to get people to not support the Black Friday tradition. He argues that the mentality that people have when shopping on Black Friday is ridiculous and dangerous. He mainly focuses on the retailer’s perspective and condemns them for their marketing practices when advertising their sales on that day. He clearly disapproves of commercials advertising the mob mentality that takes place during the sale, noting the dangers of the over excitement people experience when trying to get the products they want such as fights breaking out and people being trampled to death. However, he mentions his support for the economy the sale provides, he simply argues the idea of Black Friday has gone too far. 
The article “Friday’s Deal May Not Be the Best” by Stephanie Clifford does not attack the idea of the sale like Leonard. Instead, she focuses on the misleading nature of Black Friday in people’s beliefs that Black Friday is the one day of the year to get the best deals. She talks about how instead the weeks following Thanksgiving are actually the times with the lowest prices because stores want to empty their stock. Therefore, stores are taking advantage of the belief that people have that Black Friday has the best sales in order to get a boost in profit. This article is more of a public service announcement by letting readers know about the practice and should instead wait until after Black Friday to get better deals, instead of being fooled into believing otherwise. 
  The article “For Black Friday First-Timers, Not a Night of Conversion” by Stephanie Clifford and Christopher Maag gives people’s accounts of their first experience in the Black Friday rush. This article instead focused on different people’s first time shopping on Black Friday on Thanksgiving night with stores opening much earlier than in the past. Some most people said they would try it because it seemed fun, only to realize it was not worth it and decided not to shop on Black Friday again. This article, unlike the others, focused on the consumer’s perspective as to why they shop on Black Friday. Many answered by saying they needed to take advantage of the sales due to a rougher economy. They justified their need to shop on Black Friday by saying the sales allow not just for deals on Christmas gifts but also everyday needs and the money saved on the deals can go towards other things. Many were uninterested in going through the hassle again after their experiences. 

In all, the three articles give different viewpoints on Black Friday each with different tones. Leonard’s was clearly more argumentative by trying to getting his point across that Black Friday has gone too far and retailers are taking too much advantage of consumers. Clifford’s piece is mainly informative from the view of an expert whose findings are meant to help people realize that Black  Friday is not actually the best day for sales. This article is not actively arguing against Black Friday, but its information may give that sense. Clifford and Maag’s article is purely meant to give people the consumer’s side of the subject and how they see Black Friday. By showing a mixed reaction, the article is never arguing for or against the participation. 

No comments:

Post a Comment