Gabriel Solis
Ms. Matyakubova
English 110, Section F
5 November 2013
Journal 9
Illegal Immigration: An American Problem?
After reading both articles, “America Must Take Stronger Measures to Halt Illegal Immigration” by Michael Scott and “Illegal Immigration Does Not Threaten America” by Richard Rayner, I am rather conflicted on the issue of illegal immigration in America. Scott makes well researched arguments as to how illegal immigration negatively affects America. However, Rayner makes convincing counter arguments with similar research. That being said I have to agree with both articles in that illegal immigration does harm America, but not necessarily to the extreme extent Scott makes it seem. I do agree with the financial arguments in that a good majority of illegals use benefits from the governments paid for by American taxpayers and do not pay taxes themselves, which is upsettingly unfair. As a taxpayer myself, I would be upset to know taxes I paid went to someone who does not reciprocate to the point where they abuse the system, let alone the possibility that my taxes are supporting a criminal. If I wanted to use my money to help families in need, I would rather go to a proper charity or other non-profit organizations so I know where my money is going and that it is being used for the right reasons.
I also have sympathy for other arguments made by Scott, such as the trespassing and destruction of private property people near borders are forced to deal with. I would not be happy having to deal with strangers invading my property and destroying my livelihood with the possibility of being robbed or even killed. This of course does not mean that every single illegal immigrant is like this which is where Scott’s arguments fail to account for. It is impossible to know the situations of every illegal in the country which makes it difficult to just say kick everyone out because they only cause a problem. Many illegals are here because it is one of the not so many great choices they have to survive. Many come here for a better chance for themselves and their families to live even just a little better than before, often having to separate from their loved ones for long periods of time. These are the people that come here illegally that I know and have sympathy for their situations. It is impossible to distinguish these people from the abusers and criminals of the system. Therefore, illegals have been generalized to be seen as low life, uneducated peasants who only take jobs and money away from citizens. Many argue that they take jobs that nobody wants but I feel that no matter how bad the job may seem, there will always be someone willing to take if they have no other choice, so I find that argument to be invalid in some cases.
In the end, I agree with arguments made from both sides in that illegal immigration in America is a problem but the stigmas made against them are unfair and unjust. The overwhelming amount of illegals in the country is a real problem in several ways, but simply wanting to kick them out and lock all the doors is not exactly the route I would vote for. I believe in giving people a chance to do things the right way. Therefore, if illegals go through the system and pay their dues like everyone else and obtains a green card and eventually full citizenship, then I am all for it. However, border security does need to be better controlled because if illegals are granted the chance to become legal but borders do not keep more illegals from coming in, then we will just have another 1986 amnesty crisis.
No comments:
Post a Comment